Yes — but only under certain conditions.
Classical music is not just a subject; it is a sadhana — a discipline that demands a specific path. While online learning is possible, it may not be suitable for every student or every instrument.
🎶 Without a Strong Foundation, Online Classes May Not Help Much
If a student cannot correctly sing the basic Sargam, or has never truly experienced a pure “Sa,” then online learning will be of limited use.
Foundational aspects like:
- Understanding the essence of Sa
- Practicing Alankars and Palte
- Developing aural sensitivity through Tanpura listening discipline
These are best learned in the physical presence of a Guru. Online sessions are beneficial only for students who already have basic training — either through prior offline classes or natural listening ability.
🎹 Learning Harmonium — Highly Feasible Online
Instruments like the harmonium, where hand positions and scale are fixed, are easier to teach online.
However, some instruments — like sitar, sarod, mridangam — where the teacher must physically guide hand placement (called rakhav), cannot be taught effectively online alone.
👁🗨 In Vocal Training, Eye Contact and Taal Interaction Are Crucial
Classical vocal music isn’t just about singing raagas — it’s a deeply sensitive exchange involving:
- Eye contact between Guru and disciple
- Real-time correction of intonation errors
- Subtle grasp of taal and lay
These nuances are only possible when sitting together. That’s why even if you're learning online, occasional offline classes are essential.
⏱ Can Online Classes Save Time?
Absolutely. Online learning is a great way to save time and attend sessions from anywhere.
But remember — depth in music doesn't come from convenience. It demands focus, discipline, and direct presence of the Guru.
🎯 Conclusion: The Journey of Music Ends in Contentment
In music, there is no final destination.
A true student always feels there’s more to learn.
Anyone who says, “I’ve learned enough,” likely hasn’t touched the depth of music.
📌 My Suggestions:
- If you want to become a classical vocalist, blend online learning with periodic offline training.
- If you're learning an instrument, begin with a Guru to properly learn posture, rakhav, and hand techniques.
- Online classes are best for those who already have a foundational base.
- https://www.deckm.in/blog/blog-1/kathak-dance-online-or-offline-which-is-better-for-learning-22
- Harmonium
